Edit the Mobile Menu

Used Cars for Sale in Long Island

When you're looking for the right used car, truck, or SUV, it's important to visit a dealer you can trust. At Bright Bay Mazda in Bay Shore, New York, we're proud to say that drivers in the area have been trusting our expertise for years. Drivers from Huntington to Islip, Deer Park, and Amityville have learned why buying a used vehicle from Bright Bay Mazda is a good choice. Our selection of used cars, trucks, and SUVs is sure to offer something to fit your needs. Call us today at 855-327-2989 to learn more about our selection of used vehicles, or stop by our dealership in Bay Shore, NY, and see for yourself. 

Also, remember to take a look at our new Mazda inventory to see the wide selection of new Mazda vehicles we have in stock, including CX-5, Mazda3, Mazda6, and more! 

142 vehicles found No filters applied

  • Internet Price

    $20,899

  • List Price $17,776
  • Finance Discount
  • VIN: JM1DKBC76G0106642
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Dynamic Blue Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 32 MPG | CITY: 27 MPG
  • Mileage: 16818
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 8MU4932
  • Body: 4D Sport Utility
Come check out this "DYNAMIC BLUE" One Owner Low Mileage "Touring Premium" CX-3! This All whee ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $17,899

  • List Price $18,898
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KE4CY5F0531925
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Crystal White Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 31416
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7MU4903
  • Body: SUV AWD
Super sharp "PEARL WHITE" One Owner CX-5! Mazda Certified inspected CX-5 "Touring Model" has su ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $21,799

  • List Price $22,798
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KE4CY2G0813747
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Jet Black Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 17687
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 8MU4935
  • Body: SUV
Black Beauty!! One Owner CX-5! Mazda Certified inspected CX-5 ''Touring Model'' has Very LOW M ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $22,493

  • List Price $23,492
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KE4DY4G0678754
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Meteor Gray Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 33319
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7MU4906
  • Body: SUV AWD
Come check out this One Owner "Grand Touring" CX-5! Offered at the "right" price! This "Meteor ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $23,495

  • List Price $24,494
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KE4DY1G0762787
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Titanium Flash Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 18449
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7MU4923
  • Body: SUV AWD
Mazda Certified Inspected and serviced "Grand Touring" Top of the line CX-5!! This loaded model ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $16,599

  • List Price $17,499
  • Finance Discount $900
  • VIN: JM3KE4BY8F0527675
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Jet Black Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 40809
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 5MU4842
  • Body: SUV AWD
Great SUV at a great PRICE!! This ONE Owner "Sport" package Mazda is offered at a price you wa ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $21,988

  • List Price $22,983
  • Finance Discount $995
  • VIN: JM3KE4CY4G0818853
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Jet Black Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 7420
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7MU4927
  • Body: SUV AWD
Black Beauty!! One Owner CX-5! Mazda Certified inspected CX-5 "Touring Model" has Incredibly L ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $23,488

  • List Price $24,487
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KE4DY1G0690103
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Soul Red Metallic
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 13353
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 8MU4938
  • Body: SUV AWD
Mazda Certified Inspected and serviced ''Grand Touring'' Top of the line CX-5!! This LOW MILEAG ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $22,994

  • List Price $23,993
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KE4DY7G0709141
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Meteor Gray Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 26507
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 6MU4853
  • Body: SUV AWD
Come check out the One Owner "Grand Touring" CX-5! Offered at the "right" price! This "Meteor G ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $22,487

  • List Price $23,488
  • Finance Discount $1,001
  • VIN: JM3TB3DV4E0444253
  • Engine: 6 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Jet Black Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 22 MPG | CITY: 16 MPG
  • Mileage: 41310
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 6MU4866
  • Body: SUV AWD
Top of the Line "GRAND TOURING" Mazda Certifird inspected CX-9! This Black Beauty has it all!! ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $14,888

  • List Price $15,883
  • Finance Discount $995
  • VIN: 3MZBM1V74FM204523
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed
  • Color: Deep Crystal Blue Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 41 MPG | CITY: 29 MPG
  • Mileage: 30558
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7MU4887
  • Body: Sedan
Mazda certified inspected Come see this ONE OWNER Mazda Mazda3 "Touring" model. Super well equi ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $12,994

  • List Price $13,993
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1BM1V75E1156898
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Titanium Flash Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 41 MPG | CITY: 29 MPG
  • Mileage: 59887
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 6MU4861
  • Body: Sedan
Wow What a great car at a great price! Mazda certified inspected Come see this ONE OWNER Mazda ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $12,988

  • List Price $13,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1BM1T72F1225101
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Jet Black Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 41 MPG | CITY: 29 MPG
  • Mileage: 38076
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 3MU4731
  • Body: Sedan
Check out this One Owner "Clearly Pampered" Mazda 3 "Sport"
This Super clean Black Mica Mazd ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $9,988

  • List Price $10,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1BL1UP2D1786624
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Liquid Silver Metallic
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 39 MPG | CITY: 27 MPG
  • Mileage: 65533
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 5MU4820
  • Body: Sedan
Spend wisely when you buy this wonderfully reliable Mazda3 "Sport"! Fuel efficient as they come ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $21,880

  • List Price $22,879
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1GJ1W5XG1440574
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Jet Black Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 38 MPG | CITY: 26 MPG
  • Mileage: 26476
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 6MU4865
  • Body: Sedan
Black Beauty!! Certified Inspected Mazda6! This Mazda6 "Grand Touring" Has had only One Owner a ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $21,894

  • List Price $22,893
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1NC2PF3F0239795
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic Sport
  • Color: Zeal Red
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 28 MPG | CITY: 21 MPG
  • Mileage: 7646
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7MU4895
  • Body: Convertible
Nows your chance to get a deal on a Mazda Certified inspected Hardtop convertible! These are so ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $179,899

  • List Price $242,030
  • Finance Discount $62,131
  • VIN: SCBGT3ZA6GC055440
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: White Sand Metallic
  • Int. Color: Portland
  • HWY: 24 MPG | CITY: 14 MPG
  • Mileage: 4149
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: STK055440
  • Body: Convertible
This Bentley Continental GT is finished in a very rare and Stunningly beautiful Color combinati ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $12,988

  • List Price $13,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: WBAPL33509A405679
  • Engine: 6 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed
  • Color: Black
  • HWY: 25 MPG | CITY: 16 MPG
  • Mileage: 68772
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7MU4907
  • Body: Sedan AWD
  • Internet Special

    $41,988

  • List Price $42,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 5UXKR0C31H0V76534
  • Engine: 6 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Alpine White
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 24 MPG | CITY: 18 MPG
  • Mileage: 29973
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 5UP3508
  • Body: 4D Sport Utility
Why Pay $60,000 Plus for a X-5? This 2017 X5 xdrive 3.5xi is barely broken in and fully covered ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $12,988

  • List Price $13,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 1G4HJ5EM3BU128619
  • Engine: 6 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Cyber Gray Metallic
  • Int. Color: Titanium
  • HWY: 20 MPG | CITY: 13 MPG
  • Mileage: 34297
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 4UP3481
  • Body: Sedan
CXL PREMIUM! 3.9L Fully Loaded. Heated Leather seats Only 34,297 Pampered Miles! Thgis zIs the ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $29,888

  • List Price $30,887
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 1GYS4CEF4BR214672
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Black Raven
  • Int. Color: Ebony/Ebony Accents
  • HWY: 14 MPG | CITY: 10 MPG
  • Mileage: 65885
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7MU4915
  • Body: SUV AWD
Come see this LOW MILEAGE, Mint Condition Escalade today! This Black Beauty has it all! Highlig ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $26,998

  • List Price $27,997
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 2G1FJ1EJ1E9214175
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Bright Yellow
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 24 MPG | CITY: 15 MPG
  • Mileage: 25313
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 4UP3495
  • Body: Coupe
Camaro RS/SS! 6.2L V-8 Pushing 400 Horsepower! Bluetooth®, Power Moonroof, Automatic ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $23,988

  • List Price $24,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 1G1FB1RSXH0195186
  • Engine: 6 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Red Hot
  • Int. Color: Jet Black
  • HWY: 28 MPG | CITY: 19 MPG
  • Mileage: 16344
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 5MU4838
  • Body: Coupe
Wow! RS Pckge! Red Hot! Black Racing Stripes really make this car a head turner! Just traded! ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $13,888

  • List Price $14,887
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 2G1FB1ED5B9146580
  • Engine: 6 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Cyber Gray Metallic
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 19 MPG
  • Mileage: 71859
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7UT3616
  • Body: Coupe
RS Package! Were do you find a sports car in this price range!Just Traded. Bluetooth®[Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $43,999

  • List Price $44,998
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 1G1YE2D77E5130271
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 7-Speed Manual
  • Color: Blade Silver Metallic
  • Int. Color: Jet Black
  • HWY: 29 MPG | CITY: 17 MPG
  • Mileage: 7867
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 4UP3475
  • Body: Coupe
All new Style Corvette Stingray! Super loaded 3 "LT" Package! Original sticker of $66185 so yo ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $48,777

  • List Price $49,776
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 1G1YB2D7XG5121513
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Jet Black
  • HWY: 29 MPG | CITY: 16 MPG
  • Mileage: 7333
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 8UP3648
  • Body: Coupe
Why save a little when you can save a lot on this barely broken in Corvette Stingray? Loaded wi ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $45,988

  • List Price $46,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 1G1YH2D73F5101097
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Arctic White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • HWY: 29 MPG | CITY: 16 MPG
  • Mileage: 21648
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 6UP3584
  • Body: Coupe
Check out this "white hot" Stingray priced within reach!! Nicely equipped wit the Z51 perfomanc ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $49,988

  • List Price $50,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 1G1YM2D74F5122925
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Arctic White
  • Int. Color: Adrenaline Red
  • HWY: 29 MPG | CITY: 16 MPG
  • Mileage: 7333
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 8UP3644
  • Body: Coupe
Save $25000!!! Corvettes dont get much better looking than this Super Sharp White Stingray with ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $18,988

  • List Price $19,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 2GNFLGE37D6305089
  • Engine: 6 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Summit White
  • Int. Color: Light Titanium/Jet Black
  • HWY: 23 MPG | CITY: 16 MPG
  • Mileage: 51123
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7MU4920
  • Body: SUV AWD
What a truck!! This LTZ Equinox looks like it rolled off the showroom floor!! Loaded with MOONR ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $8,977

  • List Price $8,977
  • Finance Discount
  • VIN: 2G1WB57N591109695
  • Engine: 6 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Imperial Blue Metallic
  • Int. Color: Ebony
  • HWY: 29 MPG | CITY: 18 MPG
  • Mileage: 49974
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 7UT3622
  • Body: Sedan
WOW! You found a needle in the haystack! Original Owner Fully Loaded LS with only 49,974 Pamper ... [Read More]
 
x