Edit the Mobile Menu

Used Cars for Sale in Long Island

When you're looking for the right used car, truck, or SUV, it's important to visit a dealer you can trust. At Bright Bay Mazda in Bay Shore, New York, we're proud to say that drivers in the area have been trusting our expertise for years. Drivers from Huntington to Islip, Deer Park, and Amityville have learned why buying a used vehicle from Bright Bay Mazda is a good choice. Our selection of used cars, trucks, and SUVs is sure to offer something to fit your needs. Call us today at 855-327-2989 to learn more about our selection of used vehicles, or stop by our dealership in Bay Shore, NY, and see for yourself. 

Also, remember to take a look at our new Mazda inventory to see the wide selection of new Mazda vehicles we have in stock, including CX-5, Mazda3, Mazda6, and more! 

145 vehicles found No filters applied

  • Internet Price

    $19,495

  • List Price $20,494
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1DKBD78G0119682
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 32 MPG | CITY: 27 MPG
  • Mileage: 38714
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 12MU5085
  • Body: 4D Sport Utility
All Wheel Drive!! This Certified inspected Mazda CX-5 "Grand Touring" Has it all!! MOONROOF, Bo ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $18,749

  • List Price $19,748
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1DKBC7XG0124397
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Crystal White Pearl Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 32 MPG | CITY: 27 MPG
  • Mileage: 32452
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2MU5146
  • Body: Wagon
  • Internet Price

    $16,888

  • List Price $17,887
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1DKFB72G0132177
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Soul Red Metallic
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 32 MPG | CITY: 27 MPG
  • Mileage: 32943
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2MU5137
  • Body: Wagon
Mazda Certified inspected CX-5 "Sport" the most "car-like" Crossover on the market! This Non Sm ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $19,994

  • List Price $20,993
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KE4DY3G0654526
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Meteor Gray Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 63076
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2MU5133
  • Body: SUV AWD
Super sharp "Metoer Grey'' Mazda CX-5 ''Grand Touring''! Equipped with a MOONROOF and Bose ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $22,499

  • List Price $23,498
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KE4DY0G0689847
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Blue Reflex Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 29899
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 12MU5094
  • Body: SUV AWD
Gorgeous "Blue Reflex" Mazda CX-5 "Grand Touring" Tech!! Equipped with a MOONROOF and Bose ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $28,530

  • List Price $29,529
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KFBCM6J0427242
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Jet Black Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 3989
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2MU5140
  • Body: SUV AWD
  • Internet Price

    $24,988

  • List Price $25,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KFBDL5H0135081
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Jet Black Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 29 MPG | CITY: 23 MPG
  • Mileage: 34341
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2MU5135
  • Body: SUV AWD
Gorgeous "Black Mica" Mazda CX-5 "Grand Touring" Equipped with a MOONROOF and Bose® ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $20,499

  • List Price $21,498
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KE4CY3G0745250
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Meteor Gray Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 21904
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2MU5136
  • Body: SUV
Come in and see this ONE OWNER CX-5 with LOW MILES! This Mazda Certified Inspected Meteor grey ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $26,499

  • List Price $27,498
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM3KFBDM2J0309364
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Deep Crystal Blue Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 30 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 16683
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1MU5112
  • Body: SUV AWD
Gorgeous "Deep Crystal Blue" Mazda CX-5 "Grand Touring"! Equipped with a MOONROOF and Bose ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $14,994

  • List Price $15,993
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 3MZBM1T74GM250177
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Soul Red Metallic
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 41 MPG | CITY: 29 MPG
  • Mileage: 3538
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2MU5145
  • Body: Sedan
  • Internet Price

    $15,888

  • List Price $16,887
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1BM1V7XG1288414
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Liquid Silver Metallic
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 41 MPG | CITY: 29 MPG
  • Mileage: 11000
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1MU5107
  • Body: Sedan

Come see this very clean ONE Owner "Liquid silver" Mazda3 "Touring" Sedan!, Mazda Certifie ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $10,938

  • List Price $11,888
  • Finance Discount $950
  • VIN: 3MZBM1V72FM226567
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Blue Reflex Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 41 MPG | CITY: 29 MPG
  • Mileage: 77546
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 9MU5003
  • Body: Sedan
Wow What a great car at a great price! Mazda Certified inspected Come see this ONE OWNER Mazda ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $16,894

  • List Price $17,893
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1BM1X79G1307998
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Snowflake White Pearl Mica
  • HWY: 41 MPG | CITY: 29 MPG
  • Mileage: 27497
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1MU5119
  • Body: Sedan
"Top of the Line" Mazda3 "Grand Touring" Sedan!, Only One Owner !! Mazda Certified inspected! ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $16,888

  • List Price $17,887
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 3MZBM1L76GM265151
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Jet Black Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 40 MPG | CITY: 29 MPG
  • Mileage: 18507
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 12MU5092
  • Body: Hatchback
How about this Black Mazda3 "Touring" Hatchback? Mazda Certified inspected! Equipped with a Pow ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $10,888

  • List Price $11,887
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1BM1T7XF1235374
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Snowflake White Pearl Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 41 MPG | CITY: 29 MPG
  • Mileage: 77604
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1MU5131
  • Body: Sedan
This Super reliable and fuel efficient Mazda3 is Priced to SELL! Mazda Certified inspected Mean ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $19,899

  • List Price $20,898
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1GJ1W55G1455208
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Meteor Gray Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 38 MPG | CITY: 26 MPG
  • Mileage: 23998
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1MU5130
  • Body: Sedan
The Mazda6 was just Voted Best Certified Preowned car value by Autotrader.com....This One Owner ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $13,998

  • List Price $14,997
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1GJ1U55G1431686
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Meteor Gray Mica
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 37 MPG | CITY: 25 MPG
  • Mileage: 47764
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 11MU5064
  • Body: Sedan
Dont settle for just a car, come see and experience the Mazda 6! This One owner "sport" Model H ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $15,961

  • List Price $16,960
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1GJ1V51G1476378
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Deep Crystal Blue
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 37 MPG | CITY: 25 MPG
  • Mileage: 50541
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1MU5120
  • Body: Sedan
This One Owner Mazda Certified inspected Mazda6 "Touring" Is LIKE New!! This Car Represents su ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $20,499

  • List Price $21,494
  • Finance Discount $995
  • VIN: JM1GL1V54H1155821
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Color: Sonic Silver Metallic
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 34 MPG | CITY: 24 MPG
  • Mileage: 5052
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 8MU4964
  • Body: Sedan
You Want to buy a New car At a used car price? Heres your chance!! This Mazda Certified inspect ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $20,923

  • List Price $21,922
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1GJ1W58G1474366
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Soul Red Metallic
  • Int. Color: Parchment
  • HWY: 38 MPG | CITY: 26 MPG
  • Mileage: 17934
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1MU5117
  • Body: Sedan
This Stunning "Soul Red" Mazda6 "Grand Touring" has been Certified inspected and passed a rigo ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $12,988

  • List Price $13,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1NC2EF4A0210026
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Manual
  • Color: Liquid Silver Metallic
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 28 MPG | CITY: 21 MPG
  • Mileage: 19061
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 10MU5034
  • Body: Convertible
Super LOW LOW Mileage Mazda MX-5 Miata Miata! Super low price for this Impeccable Garage Kept M ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $27,988

  • List Price $34,265
  • Finance Discount $6,277
  • VIN: JM1NDAM75H0109783
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Manual
  • Color: White Pearl
  • Int. Color: Blk
  • HWY: 33 MPG | CITY: 26 MPG
  • Mileage: 5
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: M170692
  • Body: Convertible
Looking for great deal? How about a New Mazda RF "Grand Touring" at a preowned price? This Pear ... [Read More]
  • Internet Price

    $26,879

  • List Price $27,878
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: JM1NDAL76H0105954
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Manual
  • Color: Ceramic Metallic
  • Int. Color: Black
  • HWY: 33 MPG | CITY: 26 MPG
  • Mileage: 6908
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1MU5116
  • Body: Convertible
Miata retractable hardtop "Club" Package!! BREMBO Brakes package! Looking for great deal? How a ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $18,974

  • List Price
  • Finance Discount
  • VIN: WBA3C3G51FNS74744
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Alpine White
  • HWY: 35 MPG | CITY: 23 MPG
  • Mileage: 42450
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2MU5151
  • Body: Sedan AWD
  • Internet Special

    $48,888

  • List Price $49,887
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 1GYS4NKJ9FR747563
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Black Raven
  • Int. Color: Jet Black
  • HWY: 21 MPG | CITY: 15 MPG
  • Mileage: 36914
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2UR3920
  • Body: SUV 4X4
BLACK BEAUTY* Luxurious All Wheel Drive! Loaded with NAVIGATION, MOONROOF, Rear DVD! LOADED! ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $20,777

  • List Price $21,776
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 1GYUKHEF3AR215726
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Black Raven
  • Int. Color: Ebony/Ebony Accents
  • Mileage: 94448
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1UT3901
  • Body: SUV AWD
ESV Navigation Power Moon-Roof, Bluetooth®, Heated and Cooled Leather Seats, Every O ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $27,988

  • List Price $28,987
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 3GNTKGE78CG117256
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: White Diamond Tricoat
  • Int. Color: Ebony
  • HWY: 16 MPG | CITY: 11 MPG
  • Mileage: 59836
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 1MU5103
  • Body: Crew Cab 4X4
Nows is your chance to get that Avalanche you've always had your eye on! This Pearl white ONE O ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $18,888

  • List Price $19,887
  • Finance Discount $999
  • VIN: 2G1FK1EJ7B9101307
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Red
  • HWY: 25 MPG | CITY: 16 MPG
  • Mileage: 49848
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2UR3939
  • Body: Coupe
  • Internet Special

    $47,988

  • List Price $48,983
  • Finance Discount $995
  • VIN: 1G1YB2D7XG5121513
  • Engine: 8 Cylinder
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Jet Black
  • HWY: 29 MPG | CITY: 16 MPG
  • Mileage: 7333
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 8UP3648
  • Body: Coupe
COMPARE!!! This is not your average Corvette Stingray. This Black Beauty is Loaded with CHROME ... [Read More]
  • Internet Special

    $10,888

  • List Price $11,995
  • Finance Discount $1,107
  • VIN: 2CNFLEEW4A6348416
  • Engine: 4 Cylinder
  • Transmission: Shiftable Automatic
  • Color: Summit White
  • Int. Color: Jet Black
  • HWY: 29 MPG | CITY: 20 MPG
  • Mileage: 51796
  • Dealer: Bright Bay Mazda
  • Stock #: 2UT3923
  • Body: SUV AWD
"AWD" Just Traded! Power Sunroof, Power Seats this baby is Loaded! Only 51,796 Original Miles! ... [Read More]
 
x